← Back to articles
Polaroid of Susana Serrano-Davey's mountain bike and Carlos's, by the sea: My bike, and Carlos's

In short: fear and ability answer two different questions. Fear measures whether you feel safe, not what you can do. When you separate them, the decision you make changes.

“They got it wrong when they chose me.”

A finance director I was mentoring said this to me. I’ll call her Paula. She had just been promoted and, instead of enjoying it, she was drowning.

“This isn’t me.” “I feel small.” “They’re going to find out.”

Fear was speaking very loudly. And no wonder: a new role, more responsibility, more people watching.

So I suggested we make a list. Not of what she feared, but of what she had already done. Hiring. Firing. Closing the accounts. Negotiating with banks. The list was long.

The fear was real. So was her ability.

Two questions that aren’t the same

Paula was doing what almost everyone does when they take a big step: she was merging two questions into one.

How afraid am I?
What am I capable of?

They look the same, but they aren’t. And when we mix them up, fear ends up answering both.

What fear is really telling you

Fear answers a different question: “Do I feel safe?” Not “Can I do this?”

It’s like a warning light on your car’s dashboard. It comes on so that you stop and look under the bonnet. Not so that you write the car off.

When we start a new role, a new challenge or a difficult conversation, it’s normal for that light to come on: we’re on new ground. But the light doesn’t measure your talent. It measures how little you know the road yet.

My bike

I learnt this on a bike.

At 47, I met a man, a rather handsome man, who was a mountain biker. He invited me to ride with him the next weekend. The last time I’d been on a bike, I was about seven.

Inside: “Susana, you can’t do this.” Out loud: “Yes, of course!”

I got on at the front door and fell off five seconds later. That was ability: I hadn’t ridden for forty years. And ability can be learnt. I got back on.

Two months later, in a fit of blind love, I followed him down a deadly path. I went flying. I broke my shoulder: an operation and eighteen staples.

Getting back on that bike scared me. A lot. But that was a different question. I knew how to ride; what I didn’t know was whether I felt safe. So we chose an easy route and I went slowly, hands shaking, eyes on the ground. Step by step. And one day, I looked up.

I still get on that bike today. Sometimes it still scares me. But I have more kilometres behind me.

What to do when fear tells you “you can’t”

  1. Split it in two, in writing. In one column: how afraid am I, and of what? In the other: what am I capable of? With concrete examples of what you’ve already done.
  2. If what’s missing is ability, learn it little by little. Albert Bandura, one of the most cited psychologists of the twentieth century, showed that belief in what you can do isn’t built with positive thinking, but with small, real wins, one after another.
  3. If what’s there is fear, that’s already courage. You don’t need to switch it off. Alison Wood Brooks, of Harvard Business School, found that people who reframed their nerves as excitement before speaking in public performed better than those who tried to calm down. In the body, fear and excitement feel almost the same.
  4. Look at your list. What you’ve already done is the proof.

“I’m scared” is not the same as “I’m not good enough”

They hadn’t chosen Paula by mistake. She was scared, which is something else.

Next time fear tells you “you can’t”, split it in two: how afraid am I? And what am I capable of?

And tell me: when did you mistake fear for not being capable?

If you’d like to keep exploring, every month I share ideas and resources like this in my newsletter: serranodavey.com/suscribete

Frequently asked questions

Is fear the same as impostor syndrome?

Not exactly. Impostor syndrome is the feeling that you don’t deserve what you’ve achieved. Very often, that’s fear speaking for ability. Separating the two questions helps you see it.

How do I know if I lack ability or have too much fear?

List what you’ve already done in similar situations. If there are examples, ability isn’t the problem. If there aren’t, it’s something you can learn.

What if I really do lack a skill?

Learn it step by step, with real practice and small wins. You don’t need to feel confident to start.

Sources

Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review.
Brooks, A. W. (2014). Get excited: Reappraising pre-performance anxiety as excitement. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General.

About the author: Susana Serrano-Davey is a former CFO with over 25 years in corporate life. Today she mentors leaders and professionals, speaks about confidence and self-awareness at work, and is the author of Self-Confidence Is Overrated.

Keep reading: We’ve got confidence the wrong way round · Girls don’t need help anymore. Or do they?

Read more articles · Join the monthly newsletter